Socializing
Narcissists and Emotional Empathy: Understanding the Complexity of Empathy
Narcissists and Emotional Empathy: Understanding the Complexity of Empathy
The debate around whether narcissists can learn and mask empathy, or if it is a fundamental trait they lack, has been a subject of intense discussion in therapeutic circles. While therapists often note that empathy can be learned, the nuances of this claim can be complex and require careful exploration. This article aims to clarify the role of empathy in narcissistic behavior and the challenges in diagnosing it accurately.
Therapeutic Perspectives and the Role of Empathy
According to the therapist in the referenced text, narcissists may indeed go for individuals with empathy to learn what it is, as they find it appealing. This suggests that while some narcissists might not naturally possess empathy, they can acquire and display it, often for strategic reasons. This phenomenon underscores the idea that empathy is not necessarily an inherent, immutable trait but one that can be cultivated.
However, understanding the specifics of empathy is crucial. Emotional empathy involves automatically feeling the emotions of another person, often in a visceral, unprocessed way. Cognitive empathy, on the other hand, is more deliberate and involves understanding and responding to someone's emotions through thought and reason. Narcissists typically exhibit cognitive empathy but struggle with emotional empathy.
Cognitive Empathy vs. Emotional Empathy
Emotional empathy is characterized by the automatic, unprocessed sharing of another person's emotions. This type of empathy can be seen when you feel your own pain after witnessing someone else’s accident or experience similar joy when a family member achieves a personal goal. In contrast, cognitive empathy functions as a more rational and analytical process. It allows individuals to understand and respond to emotions without necessarily experiencing them internally.
Narcissists primarily display cognitive empathy, as evidenced by their ability to give socially appropriate responses and manage relationships. However, they often lack the capability to spontaneously share the emotions of others, even in high-stress situations.
Scientific Correlation with Brain Function
Research and medical studies, such as those utilizing functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI), have been used to observe brain activity in individuals with sociopathy. If there is no neural activity in the emotional system of the brain, a person can be classified as a sociopath, indicating an intrinsic lack of emotional capacity. Sociopaths can, however, be very skilled at faking emotions to suit their circumstances.
Therapists and psychologists are not typically qualified to diagnose conditions such as Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) or sociopathy. Effective diagnosis requires extensive time and testing, often beyond what therapists have in a typical therapeutic setting.
Therapy and the Development of Empathy in Narcissists
While the basis of empathy in narcissists is often cognitive rather than emotional, there is evidence to suggest that it can develop over time through therapy. Successful therapy, particularly when focused on deep emotional self-exploration, can facilitate the development of emotional empathy in some individuals with NPD.
According to Elinor Greenberg, Ph.D., a consultant on Narcissistic Personality Disorders and author of the book “Borderline Narcissistic and Schizoid Adaptations,” clients with NPD who show significant progress in therapy might start to experience emotional empathy for the first time. This typically occurs under specific circumstances: when the individual is very invested in their therapy, when they confide in a harmless person of lower status, and when the situation evokes distress resembling their own past experiences.
The outlined scenario of Bill, a client with NPD, provides a clear example. Bill, who had a traumatic childhood, began to develop emotional empathy after building a significant emotional bond with a subordinate at work. He felt genuine compassion for the coworker’s plight, mirroring his own past experiences.
Greenberg’s observations highlight that the development of emotional empathy in narcissists is gradual and requires specific and intense therapeutic experiences. This understanding is crucial for both therapists and individuals seeking to develop a deeper emotional connection in their relationships.
Conclusion
The discussion surrounding narcissists and their capacity for empathy reveals a nuanced understanding of both the therapeutic and scientific perspectives. While cognition and social skills are well-developed, emotional empathy remains a challenge for many individuals with NPD. Thorough therapy can foster the development of emotional empathy, contributing to a more fulfilling and emotionally connected life.