The Misunderstood Quote: Job and the True Meaning Behind 'There Is No Profit in Trying to Please God'

Introduction

The Old Testament of the Bible contains many complex and thought-provoking passages, one of which is found in Job 34:9. This verse has often been misunderstood and misapplied, leading to a lack of true comfort and understanding in times of spiritual struggle. Let's delve into the context of this quote and explore its deeper meaning.

Background of Job and the Quote

In the book of Job, an innocent man suffers terribly, prompting a debate on his righteousness and the nature of God's justice. Elihu, one of the characters, quotes a statement made by Job, which has been translated as:

"For he (Job) has said, 'It profits a man nothing that he should delight himself with God.'" (Job 34:9)

It is crucial to note that Elihu is quoting something Job is thought to have said, and this statement has a specific context within the narrative of Job's suffering. Elihu is not attributing this quote directly to Job, but rather using it to highlight Job's perceived lack of wisdom and understanding.

The Context and Speakers

The chapter in which this quote appears, Job 34:34–37, is a continuation of Elihu's speech. He questions Job’s desire for comfort and righteousness, and advises that Job should be tested and challenged further for his words. Elihu argues that Job has tried to take a stand against wickedness but has instead added to his own sin. He comments:

"My desire is that Job may be tried unto the end because of his answers for wicked men. For he addeth rebellion unto his sin he clappeth his hands among us and multiplieth his words against God." (Job 34:35-37)

Here, Elihu is clearly rebuking Job, questioning his righteousness, and challenging his assertions about God's actions.

Interpreting the Quote

It is vital to understand the full context of the passage to properly interpret the quote. Elihu is not agreeing with Job's sentiment but rather using it to highlight the perceived contradictions in Job's words and actions. The quote does not reflect the entirety of Job's thoughts or the overall message of the book. In fact, the book of Job itself ultimately supports the idea that God is just and merciful, regardless of man's attempts to please Him.

Job's journey is one of suffering and questioning, but it is also a profound examination of faith and trust. Despite his tribulations, Job remains steadfast in his faith. The verse often quoted out of context can be misleading if it is not placed within its specific narrative framework.

The True Meaning and Spiritual Insight

The original text of Job 38:8-9 provides further insight into this context. God responds to Job, chastising the idea of associating with evildoers and challenging Job directly:

"Then the Lord answered Job out of the whirlwind and said 'Who is this that darkens counsel by words without knowledge? Gird up your loins like a man, I will question you and you shall answer Me.'" (Job 38:1-6)"Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth? Tell Me, if you have understanding. Who determined its measurements? Surely you know!" (Job 38:8-9)

Here, God is correcting Job's false notion of speaking against Him. This verse emphasizes God's authority and omnipotence, challenging Job to recognize His sovereignty over the world and to trust in His decisions, even when they seem unjust to humans.

The true meaning behind the quote is not about the futility of trying to please God, but rather about the immensity of God’s wisdom and the limitations of human understanding. This understanding is crucial for those struggling with their faith, reminding them that their perception of God’s justice is limited and that divine actions are beyond human comprehension.

Conclusion

The quote "It profits a man nothing that he should delight himself with God" is often misunderstood, and its correct context is essential for accurate interpretation. Elihu's comments about Job are not meant to be an endorsement of the sentiment but rather a rebuke to Job's perceived arrogance and misunderstanding. The underlying message, however, is a profound one, emphasizing the limitations of human understanding and the overwhelming power and wisdom of God.

For those in spiritual struggle, it is important to recognize that the journey of faith often involves questioning and doubt. Understanding the full context of biblical passages can provide deeper insight and comfort, guiding us toward a more nuanced and enriching spiritual journey.