Can the UK Reunite with the EU? A Futile Resurgence of Empire Dreams

For many spirited Brexit supporters, the thought of the United Kingdom reuniting with Europe might seem like a dream fulfilled. However, the reality is far from ideal and fraught with significant barriers. This article explores the feasibility of such a proposal and explains why it is unlikely to ever come to fruition.

Empire Fever Still Lurks: A Reflection on Historical Ambitions

The call to reunite the UK with the rest of Europe resonates with a tinge of nostalgia for the glory days of the British Empire. While such talk is often met with a mix of amusement and disgust, it is indicative of a lingering sentiment among a segment of the British populace who believe that the current relationship with the European Union (EU) is not satisfactory.

EU Rejection: Practical and Legal Challenges

From a practical and legal standpoint, the idea of the UK inviting EU nations back into its fold is laughable. Every EU member state would emphatically refuse such an invitation, primarily because it would necessitate a fundamental rethink of the EU’s foundational treaties. The UK would need to reform its governance structure to align with the EU's intergovernmental processes, which is a monumental task.

Political and Social Integration: An Impossible Task

Even if the UK were willing to undergo such drastic changes, the social and political integration of EU citizens into the UK would be a daunting task. For instance, if Spain and Poland were to join, their citizens would become UK citizens, leading to demographic shifts that could disrupt the political landscape. The British would find themselves in the minority, which could lead to significant social and political tensions.

A Return to Basics: Possible Alternatives

While a full reunification seems unlikely, it is theoretically possible to explore simpler arrangements. Brexit has already sparked discussions about better trade relations, and some have suggested a more modest proposal—a general agreement on trade with a border protection clause against immigration. This arrangement would be managed from London but would have to be acceptable to all parties involved and would likely be more feasible than a comprehensive political union.

Conclusion: Reconsidering the Stars Aligning

As the UK contemplates its future relationship with the EU, it is essential to recognize the complex and multifaceted issues involved. The idea of a nation reuniting with its former partners is as mythical as it is impractical. Instead, the focus should be on finding a way to leverage existing relationships for mutual benefit, whether through trade agreements or other forms of cooperation. The UK's journey out of the EU is primarily about setting new paths forward, rather than retracing old ones.