Why People Watch Remake Movies When They Have Seen the Originals

It is a common phenomenon that people choose to watch remake movies even after they have seen the original versions. The allure of seeing how a single idea can be transformed into different stories, styles, and languages is irresistible to many viewers. While remakes can offer new interpretations and improvements, they can also fall short of the original's magic. Understanding this dynamic can shed light on why people continue to watch remakes.

Why Not Research All Previous Versions?

Many people do not take the time to research all previous versions of a piece of work before deciding to watch the remake. For example, did you watch Dirty Rotten Scoundrels starring Steve Martin and Michael Caine? Did you know it was a remake of Bedtime Story, starring Marlon Brando and David Niven? And when you were a kid, did you watch The Wizard of Oz with Judy Garland, knowing it had already been filmed half-a-dozen times? Or have you watched the BBC series Sherlock with Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman, not realizing it wasn't the first time Sherlock Holmes was brought to the screen? Were you a fan of The Man with No Name in Clint Eastwood's A Fistful of Dollars, but interested to see the Japanese original Yojimbo?

The Popularity of Remake Movies

Despite these previous adaptations, many people still choose to watch the remakes. Perhaps the most significant example is A Star is Born. This story of a struggling musician and a Hollywood actress was remade in the 30s, 50s, 70s, and the 2010s. Each remake was a hit, suggesting that the original story has enduring appeal. However, this also raises questions about why remakes are so popular. Do people assume that remakes will always improve upon the original in terms of story, production, acting, and direction?

The Dynamics of Remakes

People are generally less willing to take a risk on an original, especially if it is different from what they are used to. However, the same story can get repetitive and boring, leading to the creation of remakes. For instance, remakes in the superhero genre such as Batman and other films are often performed in multiple languages and by different actors. The only differences are in the actors and production, with the story usually remaining the same. Therefore, it is crucial to loves the original story and actors to enjoy the remake.

Why Some Remakes Succeed

Despite the common belief that remakes fall short, there are instances where remakes are successful. For example, the Charlie and the Chocolate Factory story has been remade in various adaptations such as Bollywood and South Indian films. This suggests that sometimes a remake can capture the essence of the original and bring a fresh perspective to it.

However, it is often the case that the original movie is better than its remake. Originals are typically superior and rewatchable, so many prefer to stick with the timeless classics. In fact, knowing that a remake of a great movie is happening can make people more inclined to stay home and watch the original, realizing most remakes are not as successful as the originals.

Ultimately, the decision to watch a remake depends on the quality of the original and the remake itself. While remakes can offer new interpretations and improvements, they can also fall short of the original's magic. As a movie enthusiast, it is essential to be aware of the dynamics at play and make informed choices.