Why is Kneeling During the National Anthem Considered Disrespectful?

The debate over kneeling during the National Anthem has sparked numerous discussions and often leads to passionate explanations from both sides of the issue. Some argue that it is a solemn and prayerful gesture aimed at achieving justice, while others believe it is disrespectful, aligning more with the view implied by the initial statement. However, understanding the nuances of this debate requires a clear look at the legal and societal contexts surrounding the National Anthem and the US Flag Code.

Legality and Societal Norms

The initial statement implies that people believe kneeling during the National Anthem is inappropriate, similar to how athletes might see their actions as part of a game rather than a solemn moment. The National Anthem is not just a song but a symbol that represents the unity and dignity of the nation. Its playing is a solemn moment when people are expected to show respect, often by standing and placing a hand over their heart. This expectation is not arbitrary but is grounded in the US Flag Code.

US Flag Code

The US Flag Code, a set of guidelines for the display, use, and respect of the American flag, provides a clear directive on the proper behavior at the playing of the National Anthem. According to §171 of the Flag Code:

During rendition of the national anthem when the flag is displayed, all present except those in uniform should stand at attention facing the flag with the right hand over the heart. Men not in uniform should remove their headdress with their right hand and hold it at the left shoulder, the hand being over the heart. When the flag is not displayed, those present should face toward the music and act in the same manner they would if the flag were displayed there.

These guidelines are prescribed to ensure a consistent and respectful display of reverence for the flag, which encompasses the National Anthem. However, just as people in the stands or at concession stands are expected to stand, the players question is more about the acknowledgment of a shift in cultural norms and personal expression.

The Historical Context and Personal Expression

The current context of kneeling during the National Anthem brings into sharp focus the tension between societal norms and personal expression. Many argue that kneeling is a form of demonstrating respect through its solemnity, similar to a prayer or a moment of reflection. This view has been embraced by some, especially in light of social justice issues. However, from the perspective of the Flag Code, the act of kneeling stands apart from the prescribed behavior of standing.

The historical context of the National Anthem and the flag is rooted in respect and unity. The code's directive to stand is not just a legal regulation but a collective agreement to uphold a common symbol and its associated values. Deviations from this expectation, such as kneeling, can be seen as challenging the current norms of respect and solemnity.

Broader Implications and Cultural Shifts

The situation with the National Anthem and players kneeling has broader implications for cultural norms and personal expression. A critical point to consider is the universality of gestures and their context. Just as the use of water in a baptism is a specific religious act and not universally acceptable in professional settings, acts like kneeling during the National Anthem, which carry strong symbolic meaning, may not align with the expectations of a historical and cultural context where standing is the norm.

The Steelers' attempt to stay in the locker room to avoid controversy also highlights the challenge of balancing personal beliefs with societal expectations. This debate reflects a deeper discussion about freedom of expression, national unity, and the role of sports in broader cultural issues.

On the other end of the spectrum, the initial statement criticizes the lack of respect from athletes, suggesting that such actions are unworthy of the privilege of being paid to play. This perspective emphasizes the role of individual conduct within the broader framework of national pride and leadership.

Overall, the debate over kneeling during the National Anthem is not just about personal expression but a complex interplay between societal norms, individual rights, and the enduring significance of symbols like the flag and the National Anthem. As we navigate these discussions, it is essential to understand the historical and cultural contexts that shape our expectations and guidelines for collective respect.