How to Differentiate Between a Genuine Expert and a Faker

Identifying an expert in a field goes beyond surface-level knowledge. Anyone can pretend to be an expert by superficially skimming through a topic, but genuine experts distinguish themselves through the depth, time, and quality of their knowledge. In this article, we’ll explore the nuances that help you differentiate between a genuine expert and someone who is merely pretending.

The Power of Time and Depth

If you come across someone who claims to be an expert, consider how long they have studied the topic and their actual experience. It's a common trick for impostors to skim over a subject quickly and present themselves as knowledgeable. But true expertise is evident when someone can handle real-world situations and problems effectively.

Suppose you have a problem with a machine not working during production. An expert would calmly diagnose and fix the issue efficiently. In contrast, a faker might appear confused and stressed, revealing their lack of genuine knowledge. This practical application of their skills serves as a litmus test for their true expertise.

Verifying Credentials

Another critical factor in verifying someone's expertise is their educational background and qualifications. If someone claims to be an expert in a specific field, checking their credentials can reveal a lot about their authenticity. For instance, in my field of expertise—IP law—I hold not only a law degree but also three Master's degrees in IP and a Bachelor's in Mechanical Engineering. This extensive education reflects a deep and comprehensive study of technology, law, and IP law over a decade.

Consider the case of an individual who calls themselves an IP expert but only has a law degree. This suggests they have studied IP topics for only a matter of months, not providing the depth necessary to claim true expertise. Conversely, if they have no IP subjects in their law degree, it indicates they are misleading the public with false claims. It's essential to be proactive and verify credentials to ensure you are dealing with a genuine expert.

Testing Genuine Knowledge

One of the best ways to verify a person's expertise is by asking unexpected and challenging questions. True experts should be able to answer questions related to their field without hesitation. When I have conducted such tests, I have found that some individuals either do not know the answers or struggle to provide satisfactory responses.

Consider the concept that 'the taste of the cake is in eating it.' True skills and knowledge will manifest in practical results and quality delivery. If someone's skills are mere pretense, their lack of expertise will become apparent under stress or in challenging situations. For instance, if you provide them with a complex problem to solve, a true expert will deliver a well-thought-out solution, while a faker will likely falter or provide vague answers.

Additionally, observe how they handle unexpected questions. True experts are well-prepared and can adapt to various situations effortlessly. They are not blindsided by unexpected inquiries and can provide thoughtful responses, even if the questions are basic or not commonly asked.

Conclusion

Differentiating between a genuine expert and someone pretending to be one requires a multi-faceted approach that includes examining credentials, practical application, and knowledge testing. By employing these methods, you can ensure that the expertise you seek is genuine and reliable. Remember, the true value of an expert lies in their ability to handle real-world challenges effectively, not just their ability to make grand claims.

Stay vigilant and use these tips to discern true expertise from pretense. It will serve you well in a world where misinformation and superficial claims are rampant. Happy discerning!