The Secret to Success on Plenty of Fish: Why Looks Matter More Than Profile

Have you ever started a conversation on Plenty of Fish POF and ended up getting blocked straight away? Frustrating as it might be, there could be several reasons for this. Let's dive into the common obstacles and the surprising truths about online dating.

Profile Mismatch and Opening Message

When you start a conversation on POF, your profile and the opening message are crucial. If your profile doesn't align with the other person's expectations, you might find yourself blocked. This includes interests, photos, and the way you present yourself. Additionally, the first message must be tailored to the recipient's profile and be respectful. Generic, overly aggressive, or inappropriate messages can trigger a quick block.

Previous Experiences and Varying Expectations

Not all users on POF are the same. Some may have had negative experiences in the past, leading them to be more cautious and block people quickly. Moreover, different people have varying expectations for online dating. If your approach doesn't match theirs, they may opt to block you rather than engage in conversation.

Personal Reasons and the Appeal of Physical Attractiveness

The reasons for blocking can also be personal. Sometimes, individuals have their own personal reasons for blocking someone, which may have nothing to do with you. One interesting trend on POF is that looks can play a more significant role in getting responses than profile content. Your physical appearance, especially if it aligns with what women consider attractive, can significantly impact your chances of receiving messages and responses.

Curiosity and the Catfish Experiment

Curious about the true nature of profiles on POF, myself and a friend decided to conduct an experiment. We created a catfish profile of a tall, hot, chiseled, shirtless muscular male model. Despite the lack of details in the bio, this profile managed to bypass the verification system, leading to responses from interested women almost immediately. We even tricked women into believing we were genuine by matching our profiles with a similar one.

The results were surprising and eye-opening. Women who had posted about their interest in TED talks and a cruise around the Canary Islands were keen to engage with our attractive profile, despite their profiles clearly stating they were looking for long-term relationships. It became evident that the focus on physical attractiveness can override other important factors such as interests and hobbies.

Advice for Average Guys

The key takeaway from this experience is to prioritize physical appearance. While an intelligently crafted bio and genuine interests can help, physical attractiveness often trumps all else on dating apps like POF. My best advice to any average guy using POF is to avoid the app at all costs, as it seems most women there are more interested in picking the hottest looking men, regardless of other attributes.

Conclusion

The dating game on POF is not for the faint-hearted. While you can certainly put effort into crafting a compelling profile, the reality is that physical appearance often plays a more crucial role in getting responses. It is, therefore, essential to focus on presenting your best self and, if possible, your more attractive side when using this platform.